At home and on the streets, melancholy was the shared affect, the dull pain after the sudden shock, the heartache for all bleeding hearts.
- Baas Beckings Geobiology.
- Laboratory Animals: Regulations and Recommendations for Global Collaborative Research;
- First Russian Voyage around the World: The Journal of Hermann Ludwig von Lowenstern 1803-1806!
- Mourn, and Organise! A review of Left-Wing Melancholia by Enzo Traverso - 3:AM Magazine.
Everyone spoke in the hushed and earnest tones typically heard at a funeral. Enzo Traverso, an Italian-born historian at Cornell University, has written the perfect meditation for our melancholy age. The book does not fasten on a specific argument so much as it wanders through its topics in a melancholy mood, tracing the affect of failure and defeat that pervades leftist culture in the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries. Between Hungary in and Prague in , much of the intellectual enthusiasm for communist regimes had already dimmed, but the fall of the Berlin Wall in served as the final disappointment for many Marxists, as well as for other stalwarts on the left who never quite managed to break their cathexis with official communism.
It was not a shattering surprise, but the collapse of Soviet-style communist governments across Eastern Europe brought to an end a romance with communist dictatorship that was never much more than a fantastical projection of Western dreams. Nearly all of the chapters have been published before as essays, and though it is not always clear what holds them together, the wandering may be the ideal compositional form for a cultural history that explores left-wing melancholy as an affect born of defeat.
This was an execution disguised as a book-review. Now the hollow forms are absentmindedly caressed. That was , when financial crisis and party radicalization on both the left and the right were edging the Weimar Republic toward catastrophe. This is a bracing argument.
Revolutions Are Never On Time
With the benefit of hindsight, it is especially tempting to praise Benjamin for his clairvoyant verdict on the indulgences of the bourgeois intelligentsia. But Traverso asks us to pause and consider the limits of this perspective.
Does militancy leave no room for melancholy? Is it possible that action and irony, conviction and doubt, might somehow coexist in a single soul?
Mourn, Then Organize Again
From this point of view, melancholy can help us to recall the utopian ideals that the world has dashed. As Traverso shows, bohemia was not always the island of left-wing utopia beloved in popular memory. Fascinating as such chapters may be, it is not always clear how they relate to a theoretical defense of left-melancholy. Political conviction must be tinged with regret, and ambition with sorrow for the failures of the past. A certain frustration will arise, for example, for readers who expect new insight into the published correspondence between Theodor Adorno and Benjamin the topic of the sixth chapter.
Rethinking Left-Wing Melancholia: Between Marx and Benjamin | Berkeley Social Science
It is a commonplace of modern criticism to see Benjamin as the more militant thinker, a friend to Bertolt Brecht who embraced the political possibilities of modern art-forms such as photography and film. Emotions may have a history, but left-wing melancholy cannot be confined to a particular time or place. It is our affliction as well.
The melancholic has lost not only the love-object itself but also the ability to love. He gives in to feelings of self-reproach and even self-hatred. Somewhere along this spectrum, we find the poor creature who is stricken with melancholia and just refuses to budge. He does not see mourning as a stage; he has turned it into a lifestyle.
To the person who remains fixed on a past trauma and simply cannot get on with the business of life, the demand that he stop indulging in feelings of loss will come as another psychological blow. From the authoritative Freudian verdict on mourning as healthy and melancholia as disease, it takes only a few short steps to our own emotionally sanitized culture, in which even a momentary lapse into sadness becomes an occasion for psychopharmacological intervention. The lesson here should not be exaggerated: we are not all the victims of fascist persecution.
But the way in which metrics of psychological normality can be deployed as a defense against genuine pain should serve as a cautionary tale regarding all efforts to dismiss melancholia as merely a pathological infirmity. Revolutionary Marxism itself, we should admit, all too often succumbed to the temptation to extol the strength of the mind and the health of the body.
While we have you...
Once in power, it behaved no better than its enemies; it jutted out its chin and thumped its chest and organized parades to its own magnificence. The record of Stalinist collectivization alone should suffice to disabuse the left of any belief in its own innocence. The question today is not whether the political left must finally stop mourning for the collapse of communism but whether it can survive at all if it continues to make a fetish of its own militancy.
The mood was not deflated but celebratory. These days, people are protesting less; the playful mood has given way to a grim acknowledgement of gathering damage. We live not in the aftermath of communism, but at the beginning phase of political reaction in both Europe and North America resulting in the emergence of melancholia as the governing affect on the political left.
This is not an emotion that will easily fade away—no amount of organizing can make up for the enduring feeling of a loss that is deeper than any election.
Leave it to the forces of reaction to boast of their strength. For the left, it will be crucial to hold fast to the virtues of irony and detachment—notwithstanding the imperatives of political action.
We know only that such a politics would have to remain radically open to a future beyond the certitudes of any program or script. It would need to hold fast not to the dream of a revolution triumphant, but to the memory of those who have suffered most whenever triumph becomes the highest standard of political action. Between political reality and political aspiration, however, there is always a kind of wound. Enzo Traverso is a historian of modern and contemporary Europe; his research focuses on the intellectual history and the political ideas of the twentieth century. Before coming to Cornell in , he taught political science for many years in France.
His publications, all translated into different languages, include a dozen authored and edited collections. Several of his works investigate the impact of political and mass violence in the European culture.
- Building Innovation Pipelines through Computer-Aided Innovation: 4th IFIP WG 5.4 Working Conference, CAI 2011, Strasbourg, France, June 30 – July 1, 2011. Proceedings.
- Left-Wing Melancholia: Marxism, History, and Memory by Enzo Traverso.
- Enzo Traverso | History Cornell Arts & Sciences;
- Left-Wing Melancholia: Marxism, History, and Memory.
- Visualization and Optimization.
- Cardiovascular MRI: 150 Multiple Choice Questions and Answers?
He is currently preparing a book on the representations of the Jewish intellectual in Germany, France and Italy at the turn of the twentieth century, as well as an edited book on the history of revolutions. Klarman Hall, Room K vt cornell. Overview Enzo Traverso is a historian of modern and contemporary Europe; his research focuses on the intellectual history and the political ideas of the twentieth century.